The Lord Of The Rin...
 
Notifications
Clear all

The Lord Of The Rings: The Rings Of Power: Season 2 (Amazon Prime)

3 Posts
1 Users
0 Likes
21 Views
Matt Zimmer
(@matt-zimmer)
Noble Member Registered
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 0
Topic starter  

The Lord Of The Rings: The Rings Of Power "Elven Kings Under The Sky"

Spoiler

That was a long premiere and unfortunately it FELT long. It was good. But it was also a little too much.

Interesting that Sauron didn't always have the juice he did. Seeing him at a low point was interesting. I think Adar fucked with the wrong dude.

Rare interpersonal conflict with the Elves. I think Galadriel's sins were bigger than Elrond's, if only because Elrond is probably right.

Cirdan is the first Elf we're seen with a beard. He looks weird with it.

Speaking of weird, I still haven't gotten used to the Stranger speaking.

I love that we can actually visit the Grey Havens and see how they operate. Crap like that is why I love the show.

Very, very LONG premiere. Good. But too long. 3 1/2 stars.

The Lord Of The Rings: The Rings Of Power "Where The Stars Are Strange"

Spoiler

I thought it was a big moment when Sauron referred to Celebrimbor as The Lord Of The Rings, but honestly, I believe that title is Sauron's himself.

Cirdan shaving is both good and bad. Good because he looks like an elf now. Bad because it suggests all male elves have facial hair they shave. I don't wanna know how the sausage is made there!

For the record, female Dwarves are supposed to have beards. I get they don't for aesthetic reasons, but they actually did in The Hobbit movies, so it's an actual inconsistency.

Elrond and Galadriel's contention is kind of great to me because I think Galadriel has it coming. Still Cirdan's advice to Elrond about the Rings was needed too. Neither character is entirely right or wrong.

Pretty good. 3 1/2 stars.

The Lord Of The Rings: The Rings Of Power "The Eagle And The Sceptre"

Spoiler

Pharazon is gonna be a super shitty king.

Miriel is great because she has empathy and cares about the people. Damn that eagle for showing up when it did. Although I think it showed for support for Miriel and Pharazon's assholes misrepresented the omen as his. Fuckers.

I love that Prince Durin is skeptical of the elf Sauron is impersonating because Elrond would never say such nice things to him. I love after his sincere apology to his father, his father tells him he looks terrible. I feel like there always seem to be a lot more real moments in the live-action Middle Earth stuff than there ever were in Tolkien's books.

Shelob! I can't believe they gave the Big Damn Hero moment to a freaking horse and we were supposed to root for it!

We see a palace coup pulled off here with zero actual bloodshed. That sets The Lord Of The Rings apart from Game Of Thrones entirely, and I would argue in a good way. Ned Stark never would have been beheaded if folks in Westeros just agreed to do what the Eagles told them to.

Estrid being evil is a bummer but I perhaps should not have been surprised based on where Isildur found her. Still her stabbing him in the thigh was a pretty great Meet removed link

Arondil for the save! For the record, Theo is an asshole to say the things to him he does. I don't care how much the kid is hurting, Theo sucks because it never occurs to him Arondil is hurting just as much. What a little shithead. I am fuming.

Honestly, I was a little annoyed at points by this. The ending frustrated me too. 2 1/2 stars.

ThunderCats Ultimates! Wish List: Safari Joe, Turmagar, Tuska Warrior, Topspinner, Ram-Bam, Cruncher, Red-Eye, Tug-Mug, Driller, Ro-Bear Belle, Ro-Bear Bert, Nayda, Mumm-Rana, Dr. Dometone, Stinger, Captain Bragg & Crowman, Astral Moat Monster, Spidera, Snowmeow, Wolfrat.
Check out Gilda And Meek & The Un-Iverse! Blog with every online issue in one place!


   
Quote
Matt Zimmer
(@matt-zimmer)
Noble Member Registered
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 0
Topic starter  

The Lord Of The Rings: The Rings Of Power "Eldest"

Spoiler

I feel like this series would go down better if all the episodes were dropped at once. It is far too slow-paced to be released on a weekly basis. And I LOVE the show! But the episodes are always overlong, and the ending is always unsatisfying. This would work better as a season-length binge.

Galadriel starts off the episode lacking both credibility and capital. And Elrond is spectacularly unforgiving of that. But she spends the rest of the episode building up her cache and goodwill with the Elves. Elrond saying Galadriel sacrificed herself for the Ring is not the whole truth. Because if she did, that means the Elven Rings are sinister, and secretly forged by Sauron. But the fact that she willingly gave it to Elrond without a second thought proves that is not what is going on. Been awhile since I read The Lord Of The Rings, and I only slogged through the Silmarillion once as a teenager (who was a glutton for punishment). I don't remember if the Elven Rings were corrupt or not. Galadriel giving one up so easily says they were not.

The Ents are a truly wonderous race of beings. They almost always start out antagonistic, but truly virtuous people like Arondil can talk them down and get them on their side.

Not many opinions from me about the Harfoots and Stoors and the Dark Wizard. I am in wait-and-see mode there.

I'm glad Theo sort of made up to Arondil, but I think the kid actually owed him a real apology.

I love that Estrid is busted immediately, and the show isn't gonna dick us around for episodes on end. Honestly, that would have pissed me off.

Finally, we get to Tom Bombadil and the Stranger. We are all certain the Stranger is a young(er) Gandalf, and if that is so, I feel a little uncomfortable with Bombadil being his Jedi Master. Gandalf was singularly unique among the Wizards in fighting on behalf of the races of Middle-Earth, and despite Bombadil being a jolly fellow, I got the sense he gave less than two shits about the political situation around him. Very early on in The Fellowship Of The Ring, giving the One Ring to Bombadil is seriously considered. He is the only being we've ever seen who is unaffected by it. But the reason against doing it is that Bombadil wouldn't care about it, and would easily lose track of it, or lose interest in the mission of destroying it in Mount Doom. And while that is the dominant facet of Bombadil's jolliness in the books, I don't like the show having him confound Gandalf with supposed wisdom, when ultimately Gandalf is far wiser and more righteous than Bombadil could ever hope to be.

Yes, Gandalf COULD be corrupted by the Ring like a normal person. But he actually GIVES a damn, which is why I don't like seeing a flaky dude like Bombadil being his Sage. For any other character it might have worked. Not for Gandalf though. Not remotely.

The episode starts, goes on for an hour and a few minutes, and just stops. I do believe the series would be better served to be viewed as a whole for this reason. 3 1/2 stars.

ThunderCats Ultimates! Wish List: Safari Joe, Turmagar, Tuska Warrior, Topspinner, Ram-Bam, Cruncher, Red-Eye, Tug-Mug, Driller, Ro-Bear Belle, Ro-Bear Bert, Nayda, Mumm-Rana, Dr. Dometone, Stinger, Captain Bragg & Crowman, Astral Moat Monster, Spidera, Snowmeow, Wolfrat.
Check out Gilda And Meek & The Un-Iverse! Blog with every online issue in one place!


   
ReplyQuote
Matt Zimmer
(@matt-zimmer)
Noble Member Registered
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 0
Topic starter  

The Lord Of The Rings: The Rings Of Power "Halls Of Stone"

Spoiler

The Kemen cat is the biggest little shit ever shown in Middle-Earth. He sucks so much he belongs in Game Of Thrones. The worst thing about his sociopathic evil is it's clearly working against the King building support. I get the king is a shithead too, but he's not actually stupid, and Kemen clearly is.

We saw the alliance between Adar and Galadriel coming, didn't we? Properly built up.

I wish I believed Prince Durin when he told Muriel he would never wear one of the Rings. But I don't.

The thing that bugs me about Celebrimbor is he seems to KNOW Sauron is manipulating him. And let's him anyways. It's annoying.

I think this was a legit weak episode. I hate to say it, but once the show became ABOUT the Rings of the Power, it's become a LOT less interesting. 2 1/2 stars.

ThunderCats Ultimates! Wish List: Safari Joe, Turmagar, Tuska Warrior, Topspinner, Ram-Bam, Cruncher, Red-Eye, Tug-Mug, Driller, Ro-Bear Belle, Ro-Bear Bert, Nayda, Mumm-Rana, Dr. Dometone, Stinger, Captain Bragg & Crowman, Astral Moat Monster, Spidera, Snowmeow, Wolfrat.
Check out Gilda And Meek & The Un-Iverse! Blog with every online issue in one place!


   
ReplyQuote